Showing posts with label consumer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label consumer. Show all posts

Saturday, July 12, 2014

National Commission issues notice to owners and dealer of Jaguar brand cars in India

National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission of India on 11th July 2014 issued notices to the manufacturer of luxury brand car Jaguar M/s Jaguar Land Rover India Pvt. Ltd., Tata Motors Ltd. who has purchased Jaguar brand sometime back and their authorized dealer AMP Motors Pvt. Ltd. and their directors on a petition filed by Delhi based company M/s ALM Infotech City Pvt. Ltd. through their advocate Mr. Sunil Goel of S.G.Solicitors law firm.

The petitioner had purchased the car Range Rover 5.0 S/C Autobiography for about Rs. one crore but within days of purchase it started giving trouble. Several parts were replaced again and again but problem continued. The car went to authorized dealer’s workshop for more than 20 times in about two years but dealer could not fix the snags in the car and offered sops like extended warranty and discounts on parts and labour. About Rs.20 lakh worth of parts were replaced free of charge and another Rs.20 lakh worth of parts were replaced by charging the amount to the customer. Ultimately, the purchaser approached the National Commission. The customer prayed for replacing the car with brand new car of the same or similar model and in the alternative to refund the price paid by him for the purchase with interest as also substantial amount on account of compensation for mental harassment and trauma as well as the litigation cost. The National Commission yesterday issued notice to the car maker, dealer and their directors and fixed the matter for 8th October 2014 for hearing.



If the National Commission ultimately allows the petition, it will bring ray of hope for several such customers who are facing problems in costly branded luxurious cars without any relief from the dealers and car makers. 

Friday, October 25, 2013

Supreme Court of India awards highest compensation in medical negligence case

Dear Friends,

The Supreme Court of India has pronounced a landmark judgment on 24th October 2013 on the quantum of compensation to be awarded in cases of medical negligence. This case pertains to Dr.Kunal Saha, a doctor in US, whose wife died due to medical negligence due to medical negligence of the doctors and hospital at Kolkatta about 15 years back. The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission had awarded Rs.1.34 crore which has been enhanced by the Supreme Court to Rs.6.08 crore. 

The Supreme Court, in this 210 page judgment, referred to several earlier judgments of itself  as well as of foreign courts and beautifully discussed the law of compensation in detail. The Court also advised the medical practitioners to be vigilant in future and to continuously update themselves with latest developments in medical field so that such incidents do not recur.

This judgment, I feel, will go a long way, in furthering the right to good health of the masses and will check the tendency on part of some medical practitioners to take their patients and their work lightly. 


Sunil Goel advocate B.Sc. L.Lb L.Lm